That was only my second trip with it but I like it. It has the typical walk the dog action for the most part. It seems the farther out the bait is the wider you can make it "walk". I have also had a few times where the bait would submerge slightly and I was walking the dog right under the surface and then the bait would pop out of the water looking like a jumping fish so it also has some erratic action to it. The lunker punker also throws a huge wake so it can be used is windier conditions.

I really have nothing to compare it to as I can't remember the last time I actually threw a walk the dog type bait. I am curious myself how it compares to the super magnum wood spook.