Thanks for the comments everyone. I haven't found any visual clues on Mike's or my photos to say that these were the same fish. But you never know. Hopefully someone will catch her in another year when she's 15!

Here's another close-up shot of her... I'd guess this was a fairly young fish considering here perfect fins and overall flawless condition.

http://www.ichthy.com/tmp/ and click on IM000376.JPG